The truth about the alleged punishment for apostasy in. Journalist lakshmi doesnt see any logic what islam says dr zakir naik duration. This paper explores the islamic law of punishment for the apostate. Egypts penal code is silent about any punishment for apostasy from islam. There are some socalled modernist and liberal muslims who will perhaps like to add alleged in the above sentence. Here in this video, youll see clerics of moderate muslims endorsing the death punishment for apostasy. Article 2 of the constitution of egypt enshrines sharia.
Distinguishing features of the islamic penal system, and an introduction to the three forms of punishment which islam has legislated for certain. Laws criminalizing apostasy in selected jurisdictions library of. This publication was written by michael mumisa university of cambridge, drawing on an original draft by dr. It is important to note that in many jurisdictions where apostasy is a capital offense, sentencingis conditional on the behavior once he is charged or convicted. The politicohistorical evolution of sudanese criminal laws led. The problem, they say, is in the idea being inconsistent with the maxims of civil liberties idolized in the west. Negri sembilans shariah laws do not criminalise apostasy. Assembly of muslim jurists of america the punishment for. Apostasy in islam is commonly defined as the conscious abandonment of islam by a muslim in. In traditional islamic jurisprudence, apostasy is called irtidad riddad, and apostate is called murtad. It i s because there is none to be found in alquran in regards of fixed capital punishment, in comparison for fornication and. The truth about the alleged punishment for apostasy in islam 11 the context of this hadith was the occasion when the holy prophetsa ordered a census in medina. It is mostly a political tool departing from the spirit of the religion and subject to much abuse.
The punishment for apostasy in the islamic juristic tradition in the public and cosmic order of the abode of islam, that grand fabric of diverse kingdoms and peoples bound together by a belief in islam s legal order and in belonging to the community umma of muhammad. A historical perspective david cook rice university 1. Apostasy from islam 251 and defensive about this subject, and both of them carefully ignore the historical material that would destroy their theses. A detailed discussion about the regulations islam has set in regards to dealing with crime in society. Since, a census, by its very nature, is a broad ranging entity, the most broadranging definition by. The punishment for apostasy in the islamic juristic tradition. Third, we find that many ahadith simply list laws, principles etc that do not originate with those ahadith but are. One of the questions most frequently raised about islam relates to the punishment of apostasy in islam. For instancedefendants, in afghanistan, brunei, sudan, and yemen, a conviction for apostasy can bevacated if the defendant denounces his new faith and rejoins islam.
An apostate is someone who leaves the religion of islam for another religion. Pdf clarifying the islamic law of punishment for the. Transgression against all of these universal needs highway robbery. Effect of apostasy on marriage under muslim law ipleaders. Freedom of religion, apostasy and islam abdullah saeed. The punishment for apostasy lies in the hand of god almighty, against whom the offence has been committed.
Apostasy is riddain islamic jurisprudence and is punishable by hadd, which is a punishment fixed either by god in the quran or in hadiths traditions of the prophet. This suggests that the hadith was not very widely known or acceptable to scholars even by the middle of the second century. Contemporary egyptian jurisprudence prohibits apostasy from islam, but has also remained silent about the death penalty. This article sheds light on the islamic legal ruling concerning apostasy riddah. Attention is drawn frequently to the universal declaration of human rights, article 18, which declares that all people should be free to change their religion. This, for very obvious reasons, is due to the fact that the greatest triumphs of the true religion of allah have throughout lain in the fact of its being extremely rational, persuasive, and human. It is often noted simply that the death penalty is a generally accepted punishment for apostasy in islamic. Would abolition of the death penalty be unfaithful to the message of islam.
And to quote one more apologist for islam mohammed ali, m. Islam has been referred to, as a challenge to christian missions. Mohammad habbash director of the centre for islamic studies in damascus and with. But unlike judaism and christianity today, islam is known to go further and condemn them to death. Islamic law for mandatory fixed capital punishment for apostasy. The issue of apostasy in islam yaqeen institute for. The majority of scholars in islam stand for the punishment of an apostate. Critics argue that the death penalty or other punishment for apostasy in islam is a. Introduction in the past, muslim countries were not only like the nearby christendom, but the punishment for apostasy heresy was less of a phenomenon in muslim lands than medieval europe, for example. The quran and sunnah reject capital punishment for apostasy.
Apr 22, 2019 it is true that some muslim states such as iran, pakistan, afghanistan and sudan still have it as a criminal offence punishable by death. Since, a census, by its very nature, is a broad ranging entity, the most broadranging definition by him was given in the context of that particular occasion. In fact, there is no worldly punishment mentioned for the offense. May 06, 2019 no capital punishment for apostasy in islam. Prior to that, the authors will discuss the definition of apostasy in islam, when and how can someone turn into an apostate, what. Introduction apostasy from islam is a subject that has attracted some attention from the scholarly community during the recent past. In shariaah, death is the punishment for leaving the muslim faith. Muslims i mean humans in this religion need to deal with these questions in. Thats because islam teaches that apostates are to be killed. Its law 11 of 2004 specific traditional sharia prosecution and punishment for apostasy, considering it a hudud crime punishable by death penalty.
However section 48 of its shariah offences enactment punishes muslims who claim himself not a muslim to escape the jurisdiction of shariah laws with fine not more than rm5,000 and not more than three years jail or both. Kuala lumpur, aug 9 islam prescribes death against muslims who leave the religion for atheism, if they are stubborn and refuse to repent, according to negri sembilan mufti datuk mohd yusof ahmad. The post911 war on terror has underscored the crucial importance of understanding the issue distinctly in its religious and political contexts. Doctrinal differences, however grave, cannot be deemed to be apostasy. This is especially noteworthy considering that the quran describes two episodes that bear on the issue of apostasy. The punishment for apostasy in islam is supposedly death and afghanistan being an islamic country, his fate was known. One of the worlds most respected sunni scholars, yusuf alqaradawi, admitted in 2012 that if muslims had gotten rid of the apostasy punishment, islam wouldnt exist today. Is apostasy punishable by death in islam even if the one. But i have read on another website that the apostate who is to be put to death is the one who wages war on islam muhaarib. The issue of apostasy in islam yaqeen institute for islamic. I will address the socalled apostasy hadith firstly islam allows for the freedom of religion, therefore, is someone apostatizes they are not going against freedom of religion and are protected. Sharia law and the death penalty penal reform international. The punishment of the apostate according to islamic law. Section 4 of the dissolution of marriage act, 1939 does not apply to apostasy by the husband.
We know from historic islamic documents that during muhammads lifetime, and the lifetimes of the next four rightly guided caliphs, tens of thousands of. In view of this fact there is an urgency now as never before to present the actual injunctions of islam related to this problem. Related verses in the old and new testaments, some narrations from the messenger mohammad, and the quran reinforce our opinion. The punishment for apostasy is similar to treason in most countries. Apostasy in islam international institute of islamic thought. It was the holy prophet of islam peace be on him who really set the pace 1400 years ago by proclaiming, there is no compulsion. Apostasy from islam from muslim husband will have immediate effects of dissolution of marriage. Before discussing the issue of hadith and apostasy, a number of observations should be noted. Search for library items search for lists search for contacts search for a library.
Doc punishment for apostasy in islam mohammad mojib d. Islam recognizes the freedom of religion as a right for every individual. After the concept of jihad, apostasy is most frequently cited by. Astonishingly enough, he was not apologizing for the beheading, torture, burning and murder of millions, but. The truth about the alleged punishment for apostasy in islam xi the name of muhammadsa, the holy prophet of islam, has been followed by the symbol sa, which is an abbreviation for the salutation sallallahu alaihi wasallam may peace and blessings of allah be upon him. Capital punishment for apostasy in islam and stoning to death in islam are controversial topics. The punishment for apostasy from islam is a controversial topic for muslims living in the west and for exmuslims everywhere. Punishment for apostasy in islam islam and the quran. Malaysia cant enforce, but penalty for leaving islam is. However, under pressure from western nations, he was released on the grounds that mentally he is unstable. But if they turn renegades, seize them and slay them wherever ye find them. This article mainly reassesses ghazalis contribution to the islamic juristic discourses on apostasy, especially the implication that an evolution of the concept of apostasy. Punishment by death for apostasy from islam is firmly rooted in islam s foundational texts both the koran verses such as 2. The most important reason to forbid apostasy in islam refers to its concept.
And punishment by death for apostasy from islam is firmly rooted in the most holy muslim textsboth the koran, and the hadithas well as the sacred islamic. First, the quran, the most important text of islam, does not specify any worldly punishment for apostasy, let alone death. It includes the act of converting to another religion or nonacceptance of faith to be irreligious, by a person who. What is the legally prescribed penalty, if any, for apostasy alriddah, and how does this relate to the demand for religious tolerance as stipulated in verse 2. Moreover, assuming that it is a legally prescribed penalty and that, as is stated explicitly in authoritative islamic texts, the legally prescribed penalties serve to atone for a persons sin, is the death penalty for apostasy to be consid. After the concept of jihad, apostasy is most frequently cited by christian missionaries as a negative dimension of islam. The penalties for apostasy in islam by abdurrahmanildjaziri introduction the renaissance of islam has been stimulated strongly through a repeated increase in the price of oil since 1973. Abdullah saeed and hassan saeed freedom of religion, apostasy and islam,ashgate publishing, march 30, 2004,isbn. It was the holy prophet of islam peace be on him who really set the pace 1400 years ago by proclaiming, there is no compulsion in deen. Among the several demands being made by the mullas in pakistan, it is being fervently suggested that the ahmadis, being apostates in. This book, by a former chief justice of pakistan, examines each and every aspect of islamic jurisprudence connected with the question of apostasy in a detailed manner. It is clear from the quran that there is no punishment for apostasy.
Mughal the basic charter for human rights was acclaimed by the united nations in 1948. If rejecting one of the pillars of islam is considered to be a crime warranting war against such people, it is only logical for the prescribed punishment for apostasy in islam to be death. Even though his crime is so great, he is given a last chance, a respite of three days in which to repent. No capital punishment for apostasy in islam ahmadi responses. No, just leaving islam wont get you death penalty, but after leaving islam, if you go against islam and try to drag more people out of islam by false information and propaganda,yes,then you deserve death. Laws criminalizing apostasy in selected jurisdictions. The punishment for the offence of apostasy under the controversial islamic penal law of hudud is death. In others, there is a variation in the use of capital punishment. Many people believe that capital punishment for apostasy in islam is a problem. I have read in some of your answers on the issue of apostasy that the punishment for the apostate is to be put to death.
Jul 05, 2017 in the public and cosmic order of the abode of islam, that grand fabric of diverse kingdoms and peoples bound together by a belief in islams legal order and in belonging to the community umma of muhammad. Punishment for apostasy in islam prophets and messengers. If a muslim apostatizes and meets the conditions of apostasy i. At present the evil of apostasy has spread extensively among muslims because they are unfamiliar with their religion. With this has come a new awareness of legislation in the islamic states. Apostasy in islam project gutenberg selfpublishing. This book argues that the law of apostasy and its punishment by death in islamic law is untenable in the modern period. The result is that apostasy of the husband is still governed by old law under which the renunciation from islam by a husband will result in complete and. Why death is the punishment for apostasy islam question. Punishment for apostasy in islam zakir naik answers youtube. Archived pdf from the original on 4 september 2014. Introduction the issue of apostasy irtidad and the punishment that islam has prescribed for an apostate is one of the least known and understood part of the shar ia islamic laws. Irtidad, or apostasy, is defined as turning away from islam or severing the ties with islam1 and an apostate in arabic, murtadd is one who turns his back on religion. In several islamic countries such as sunni saudi arabia and pakistan, as well as shia iran, both hudud and qisas type capital punishment is part of the legal system and in use.
1494 1416 83 1556 230 672 1049 328 1282 743 454 549 913 1531 791 1082 371 776 333 1144 1042 1526 635 947 612 1367 859 1175 967 837 40 129 237 813 1488 396 918 1398 465 729 826 871